Drake and Josh have different recollections of an embarrassing incident from six years ago when they attended a San Diego Padres baseball game.

Drake's new girlfriend turns out to be a very tough cookie; the typically smooth Josh has trouble impressing Mindy's parents.

Megan promises to cease pulling pranks for three months if Drake and Josh agree to house the sheep she adopted. It seems like a good deal to the boys, until they discover what damage an unpenned sheep can do.