Drake and Josh are set up in a plot to sell stolen Gary Coleman grills and end up in jail when the FBI thinks they masterminded the deal.

Josh befriends Drew and Drake gets jealous, so he buddies up with Jerry, resulting in escalating one-upping.

Drake's academic future is in peril when he's wrongly accused of pulling a practical joke on a teacher. To help Drake avoid a punishment of suspension, Josh takes up his stepbrother's case with the school's Honor Council.