While getting out of the tunnels, Patricia sees Eddie and Mara together and yells - causing them to wake up. They quickly get a picture of their "ghost" (which happens to be Amber) during their cellar stake out. With photographic evidence and Mara's theory that their ghost is the "Unknown Ruler", their story could destroy the Sibuna's secret mission! Nina realizes that the dollhouse is missing and Jerome gives the dollhouse to Jasper who calls the Collector about it. The Collector takes the dollhouse and doesn't bring Trudy back. Getting angry, Jasper takes his hood off and Jerome is shocked to find out who the Collector is.

After Jasper rips off the Collector's hood, Jerome learns that Rufus is back! The Sibunas learn that Eddie had backup files on a USB drive, even though they tried to infect the picture files on his computer, so Nina dispatches her friends on different missions; Fabian has to try and convince Joy not to run the story, Patricia must apologize to Eddie, and Amber and Alfie must steal Eddie's camera. Jerome and Jasper follow Rufus and Jerome tells Jasper who he is, and they fall back. Vera finds another reflector; a piece of stained-glass from the window in her room.

Joy agrees not to run the story, on the condition that Fabian kisses her, Nina overhears it and is dismayed until Fabian tells Joy he can't do it and reveals his true feelings for Nina, but Joy decides not to run the story anyway; Eddie reconciles with Patricia. Alfie and Amber steal Eddie's camera and learn that Jerome stole the dollhouse and the two confront him. He then reveals Rufus is alive and that he is blackmailing Jasper with the threat of harming Fabian and that Vera is working for him and they find out she is a double-agent. The Sibunas and Jerome try to tell Victor this but he doesn't believe them. Amber and Patricia then overhear that Victor has three reflectors and Vera overhears that the Sibunas have the remaining three. Rufus then visits Trudy and interrogates her about the dollhouse, but when she doesn't give enough information, he tells her he no longer needs her, much to Trudy's dismay.