It's Nina's unlucky day when Victor padlocks the attic door to stop her going up there again. Now she can't get to the puzzle pieces! She doesn't even know the worst part yet - Jerome has contacted Rufus and is now spying on the Sibuna gang for him.../The Sibunas plan to go down into the cellar, to collect some of the elixir and try to crack the latest clue.

The Sibuna crew decide to induct Alfie unaware that he's been leaking information to Jerome. Nick goes to embarrassing lengths to apologize to Mara. Nina hears another mystical voice and locates the next clue and puzzle piece.

Alfie confronts Jerome when he discloses that he's has been working for Rufus Zeno. Fabian confides to Nina that he's beginning to suspect that the coven has misidentified "the Chosen One." During a spat between Alfie & Jerome, Vistor intervenes and stumbles upon sketches of the puzzle-piece relics. Meanwhile Nina and Fabian find the last of the relics.