Fabian figures out that the newest riddle refers to the grandfather clock in the hallway but the secret compartment is empty. Alfie catches him in the search and the Sibuna crew misleads Alfie with a story about aliens.

When the Sibuna crew try Nina's numbers on the latest puzzle piece mysterious writing appears on the wall. Meanwhile Mick returns and his comments to Amber are misinterpreted.

Mick plans a candle-lit dinner for Mara but jealous Jerome seeks to sabotage it. Meanwhile Fabian and Alfie go back to the cellar to get another sample of the elixir but Alfie has a flashback and panics.