Eli finds out more about Nate and Beth's engagement being called off. Keith and Eli help a Methodist minister with a lawsuit against his own church, and Taylor and Matt find out about their baby's health.

Eli, Maggie, Taylor and Matt all go on a road trip to Sonoma to fight over a client. During their vacation, Matt recognizes a woman that he went out with before, which he never called back. Maggie and Eli are left alone, and by day they carry on with the court case about a woman and a painting, and by night they are sleeping together. Meanwhile, back in San Francisco, Jordan takes Patty out on a "date" and bumps in to his ex-wife. Soon, everyone's back in San Francisco, and Dr Chen reveals all to Nate about his father.

Still estranged from his brother and Chen, Eli struggles to understand his visions of gladiator era and present day Rome as the Sam Russell trial moves forward. Meanwhile, Maggie maneuvers a little revenge into the proceedings, Jordan has news about the firm, and Taylor challenges Matt about what kind of father he's going to be.