When a teenaged girl is expelled for playing George Michael's "I Want Your Sex" during an abstinence education assembly at school, the pop superstar retains Eli's legal counsel on the girl's behalf. Taylor and Dowd sue a son for his bone marrow, and Nathan helps Eli find a surgeon.

Eli takes on Nate's case when he's accused of malpractice, but Nate's secrets jeopardize the case and cause Eli to have visions of the day his father died. Taylor's attempt to stave off Dowd involve her father and then Eli.

Eli's practical joke against Dowd results in Taylor taking on a gay chimpanzee case, and Eli enlists Bennett's help when his vision leads him to a prisoner who is the victim of a vindictive warden. Meanwhile, the law firm is visited by one of its partners, Marci Klein, who wants to investigate as to why the law firm was losing its Fortune 500 clients.