Esther must convince Levi to bring John back into the fold; Levi is confronted about by Amish leaders from around the country about his vanity; Big Steve travels to Iowa to rescue an Amish girl; Merlin sends a very personal message to Wayne.

External pressure forces Levi to make changes. Caleb starts fresh in Indiana. Esther prepares to reclaim her family's name, while John feeds information to law enforcement. Merlin adds an ally as Wayne comes under attack.

Levi gets closer to marrying Esther; John gathers new information to use against Levi; Wayne gets revenge on Ruck just as the Church begins to question Wayne; Merlin learns a new skill and looks for the most feared Amish man in the world, the Bear.