Levi looks to make amends with the Bishop by punishing one of his own. Alan goes to court to find out if he will wind up in prison. Wayne gets church approval to take over Ohio's Amish Aid. Merlin seals an alliance.

Never-before seen footage and exclusive interviews show what really happened behind the scenes during this season's run of "Amish Mafia." The group talks about its reaction to the show and shows proof that the show is absolutely real.

Merlin takes it upon himself to educate everyone about the true meaning of Christmas by any means necessary; Levi uses the holiday to make money off of the English; Wayne protects his community while Esther reunites with John Freeman.