Ashley challenges Buddy to a cake challenge. A survivor of a subway construction accident makes a request for Buddy to make a cake thanking those who saved his life.

A new customer comes to the bakery looking for Buddy and his bakers to create a special cake that grows a mustache. It's Buddy Jr.'s First Holy Communion and Buddy has to make the perfect cake for the event to please his toughest critic and client – his wife.

Buddy and his team are tasked to make a special cake for the United States Navy for their annual submarine ball. Mauro is challenged to make a cake for a girl's Bat Mitzvah where the girl, her mother, and grandmother all have different ideas for how the will be designed.