It is Buddy's wife Lisa's birthday and he wants to surprise her with a truly one-of-a-kind cake. Plus, Mama makes a huge announcement to her family about the future of the bakery.

Buddy bakes a yummy cake for the Coney Island Polar Bear Club and is invited to take an icy winter swim with them. But will he take the plunge?

Buddy is asked to make wedding cakes for fourteen couples getting married in a mass wedding on Valentine's Day. Cousin Anthony asks someone at the bakery to be his valentine.