A war breaks out when the Carlo gang are challenged to show their shooting skills in order to make a paintball cake. It is also the annual Throwback Cannoli Day at the bakery.

Buddy makes a retro cake for an '80s tribute band. He also takes a trip down memory lane when his birthplace of Little Ferry, New Jersey presents him with the key to the city.

Buddy is asked to make a mechanical bull cake. It is also the anniversary of the barber's shop where Buddy has had his hair cut since he was a child, so he makes them a cake.