When the heroes quest to stop Balthazar from turning forest folk into household objects, Herbert realises that he can defeat the wizard's spell by using the magic tricks he has practiced. Blossom is particularly intrigued by Herbert the Peculiar's tricks, not to mention his stage name, so when Herbert himself is transformed into a table lamp, it's Blossom the Very Impressive to the rescue!

The Witch, who was trapped in a Merhaven clam shell while pinching a pearl, grants Blossom a single wish to thank her for releasing her and saving her life. Blossom excitedly chooses a mermaid's tail to improve her swimming. However, when the Merqueen complains that her pearl is missing, and the heroes have to quest to get it back, Blossom soon realises how tricky a mermaid's tail can become on land.

The heroes are on a quest to find the vault containing the Amulet of Answers and protect it at all costs. But the Riddlemaster is back, and he manages to trap them in his castle, tricking Herbert into handing the Amulet of Answers over to him. Now he has all the answers to every question ever asked, and the heroes must find a way to outwit him - even though he knows what they are going to do next!