For decades, on the outskirts of Louisville, KY, thrill-seeking teenagers have dared each other to walk the rickety Pope Lick Train Trestle in hopes of glimpsing an evil Goatman. But locals are horrified when the creature's death count becomes real.

When the body of devout 16-year-old Jeannette DePalma is found near the site of rumored witch activity, police officers, reporters, and a local church leader insist that she fell prey to the deadly rituals of a local coven.

When a space-obsessed mechanical genius mysteriously vanishes after building a UFO in his backyard, his friends and family are left to investigate the possibility of an intergalactic journey.