Herman has some bad news for the returning Margaret (who has some for him in return). Herman confesses that he cheated on Margaret by kissing the ice cream woman--but only after Margaret confesses to kissing a man during her trip to Greece.

On Halloween, Emily is afraid of the costumes and Taylor faces a crisis of confidence as an actor.

Wood and Ava don't approve of Molly's date for the Sadie Hawkins dance; Herman finds out that his ancestors came from Scotland.