Struggling to cope with the loss of his arm---and his self-esteem---Kyle asks Syd to help a hard-living baseball prospect pass a physical while Jim appears on TV to offer pet care advice.

Syd risks losing everything as she tries to help Kyle deal with his amputation; Heather fears an evil spirit has stolen her soul; and Robbie messes up the negotiations for Jim and Joanie's morning show.

The opener of a two-part Thanksgiving episode finds Syd on a road trip with three lost souls; and Robbie planning a reenactment of the first holiday with a fair-weather friend.