Paul Shealey is known as a fashionable ladies' man in Jacksonville, FL, so when his body is discovered in a creek, investigators turn to his jilted romantic partners for answers.

When Nikkie Halpin is killed in a home invasion with no signs of forced entry, police investigate the men closest to her, including her boyfriend, ex and former husband.

A New Jersey community is left in shock after a popular teen is found murdered in her bedroom, and detectives suspect her plans for prom may have spurred the killer's violent actions.