Tony and Paulie visit their old neighborhood in Brooklyn when new evidence surfaces about the murder of their best friend 12 years ago.

Rachel's doctor finds a lump in her breast; the Scalis wait anxiously for the biopsy results. Tony and Paulie aim to con a con man who's been gambling with retirees' money on the stock market.

Paulie catches a thief who turns out to be a homeless boy caring for his two younger brothers.