The bakers aim to stump the stabbers with their lifelike cake recreations of items found in the produce aisle, culminating in a round one taste test elimination. In round two, hosts John Henson and Jocelyn Delk Adams challenge the remaining bakers to wrap their cakes in edible plastic.

Things get meta when the bakers make cakes based on other baked goods from the bread aisle. Then, hosts John Henson and Jocelyn Delk Adams charge the bakers with creating cakes that replicate liquids. A tie between stabbers leads to a decision breaking taste test.

The bakers must create cake replicas of items found in the dairy aisle of a real grocery store. After hiding their cakes, two teams of stabbers set out to uncover what's real and what's cake. Then, hosts John Henson and Jocelyn Delk Adams challenge the bakers to design realistic canned goods out of cake.