Joey and a fan bond over missing their proms during a 1980s theme night; an attempt is made to lure Donnie to a cabin; and a comedian tries to bypass security and invite the New Kids on the Block to her comedy show.

The guys feel exhausted prior to their big cruise concert, so rehearsal is a struggle; a fan gets nervous before spending some one-on-one time with Jordan; a woman plots to get her neck brace signed by Joey.

Jenny McCarthy's radio show is broadcast from the boat; Donnie bonds too much with a male fan; a singing rehearsal with Joey doesn't go well for a fan; the New Kids on the Block host a toga party.