Melissa's surprise party is finally here, but her friends still don't know whether Jordan will jump out of her cake. Augie enlists Johnny's help to get Jess a special moment with Donnie, hoping to make this 5th anniversary a night she will never forget.

It's the final night on the cruise and the New Kids prepare to go out with a bang. Meanwhile, Beth tries to get one-on-one time with Donnie, Jess finally enjoys VIP treatment, and Melissa gets the surprise of her life.