As the cruise comes to an end, the ladies prepare to say goodbye to four days of magic with NKOTB. Meanwhile, the Seattle Super Fans get to live out a fantasy beyond their wildest dreams.

In the second-season opener, fans set sail for Grand Turk Island with the band, and five groups of passengers share the dreams they hope will come true on this cruise.

Joey and a fan bond over missing their proms during a 1980s theme night; an attempt is made to lure Donnie to a cabin; and a comedian tries to bypass security and invite the New Kids on the Block to her comedy show.