Helena Jayne Bryant notices things missing; it takes a sinister encounter with her home invader to make her finally wake up; Brian O'Neill's Seattle condo turns into a war zone when he looks under his bed and finds a phrogger with a knife.

Sherry Lovell blames her grandchildren for hoarding food, until she faces the culprit; it's a man from her past hiding in her crawlspace; Paul Haynes returns from overseas and finds four phroggers on his balcony, triggering a nightmare.

After Heidi Lane moves to the big city, her underwear starts disappearing; she spots a man peering down through holes in the ceiling; when Jordan Buranskas can't find her purse, her boyfriend plays back security footage.