Annemarie's father was an avid collector, and when he died, he left behind an assortment of historical artifacts, fossils and other oddities. Matt and his team help her dig through a basement full of boxes, hoping to find both valuable items and cherished family heirlooms. Things get emotional when Annmarie is joined by her mother and daughters to go through the collection one last time.

Bess is a single mother of two whose family has lived in the area for seven generations. Her farmhouse is filled with antiques, vintage furniture and artwork. She also has a barn with old whaling equipment and even more family heirlooms. Anxious to downsize, she calls Matt and his team for help. They clear out the collections and find an assortment of historical artifacts that Bess never knew she had.

Leila and Don are lifelong New Yorkers selling their unique home in Queens and moving to the Hudson Valley. Before they can put their house on the market, they'll need Matt's assistance finding misplaced heirlooms that range from a piece of tile from Ellis Island to a radio from the 1939 World's Fair. Looking for these lost items puts Matt and his team in a New York state of mind.