Mike, Jen and Rich must decide if they are going to take on a 1735 Cape Cod with an "off-center" chimney and a stormy history or an 1830s Colonial home that is rumored to be the Old John Carver Inn.

Mike, Jen, and Rich have to make a tough choice between two 1800s Greek Revival homes. The first property is covered with gingerbread charm and historical detail, while the second has a plain white exterior that hides tons of industrial-age character.

Mike, Jen and Rich consider two homes that could not be more different from one another. One is a Dutch Colonial loaded with detail and a hefty price tag, while the other is a 1800s Cape Cod that's full of potential but stripped to the studs.