Sam's newfound self-confidence is shaken when she learns her new boss is a blast from the past. Meanwhile, Felicia errs in how to congratulate her boyfriend on his promotion. And Olivia makes a life changing decision.

Sam questions if she can move on at work from her old self, while also trying to navigate a relationship with a normie; Carol snoops around Sam's room and makes a terrible discovery; Joel and James have a night out.

After Sam learns that Carol invaded her privacy, the two have an explosive fight, leaving Bob to try to mediate; just as things are going well with Peter, Felicia gets an unwelcome visitor from her past.