In 1991, Will visits Jenna in Hollywood en route to completing a mission; Craig is disappointed by both Aaron and Sam; and in 2005, the gun resurfaces and another cryptic note is received, this time by Will.

Sam and Craig host Thanksgiving 1992, where two unexpected guests create tense moments as an affair is revealed, a grudge is held and a marriage of convenience is no longer.

Sam's 1993 birthday includes a fatal error at the hospital, a bombshell dropped on Aaron, a confession from Jenna and an important encounter for Carla.