At a pivotal moment for the Bowen family, Ranger learns that his Dad is plagued by an arch nemesis from his youth. Tired of seeing his dad live in someone's shadow, Ranger takes matters into his own hands.

When the student ID card machine malfunctions, Gortimer, Mel, Ranger and Catherine swap identities. As they walk a mile each other's shoes, will they gain a new perspective on the friends they thought they knew so well?

When Mel starts seeing a mysterious horse everywhere she goes, Ranger warns it's the legendary -- and much feared -- Night Mare of Normal Street. In order to rid herself of the nightmares, Mel must overcome her greatest fear.