Gavin finds that he has more in common with Victoria than he thought when he bumps into her at his AA meeting and she convinces him to go undercover as an investigative reporter to get a story on national television. Meanwhile, Dylan tries to get old high school pictures from everyone and uncovers that Penny has a secret past that no one knows about.

Jake finds out that Dylan has an ex-husband and tries to keep cool until Gavin reveals who Dylan's ex-husband really is. Meanwhile, Penny goes to a costumed wedding reception and brings along Frank, who finds that being in costume has extra benefits when he thinks he's found his very own Southern belle.

Gavin shows up for work looking like a mess after being kicked out of Penny's bed in the middle of the night after she thinks he is getting emotionally involved in the relationship. Jake jumps in to keep the show running, but ends up bringing more havoc into the situation. Meanwhile, Dylan calls upon Victoria for help buying a car.