After a year on the run, hiding in Mexico on a private island run by Jeffery Hepstein — a billionaire who faked his own death — Pauly returns to serve up some ethnic, bogan, burnout-fuelled cheesy pizza. Pauly reopens the Fat Pizza shop with Bobo, his old pizza chef, but Bobo's PTSD gets in the way of a perfect opening.

Pauly visits Julian Bausage in prison and tells him about his time hiding from the authorities in Mexico on a private island run by billionaire Jeffery Hepstein. Later, Pauly interviews new staff before the store reopens, reaps the benefits of joining a local businessman's club, and has second thoughts about his decision to bring Bobo back.

Pauly fires Bobo after discovering he's been chopping up the customers. Needing new staff, Pauly hires his cousins, Lino and Mary, to help run the restaurant. Cop Richard Head tries to take down Pauly for taking advantage of his daughter but bashes the wrong driver. Pauly's new driver has his kidney harvested by the cartel. Pauly wakes up in the wrong bed after mixing his medication.