Richard Paul White's sister Maureen loves and fears her brother, but after a childhood of devastating abuse, she sees there is something not quite right with her older sibling and the violent stories he tells.

William Choyce's ex-wife, Alice, and daughter, Crystal, are grateful to be alive and together after they survived living with a serial killer as he descended into madness.

Brian Hummert's son David is devastated when his mother is found murdered in 2004, but as the police investigation picks up steam, David realizes that the truth may be even worse.