Nina and Michael flip their first historical house, only to find that the Historical Society, not Nina, gets the last word on a major rehab decision; Nina sells a multimillion-dollar home for over list price in record time.

Michael and Nina work with a questionable investor who hands them a very small budget, a half completed house and a strict deadline; every new obstacle brings out the devil in Nina as her budget dwindles and her temper rises.

Nina and Michael take on their first renovation client, a family that returns to Indiana and buys a childhood home in Eden Estates; it's a sweet, sentimental rehab until a major mishap puts Michael and Nina's problem-solving skills to the test.