After Alex reveals he "faked it," Whitney decides they need to come clean about their past lies. Lily reveals too much about Whitney's former life to Alex. Meanwhile, Mark hires R.J.,, the new bartender at Low Bar, proving to be fresh meat for Roxanne and Lily.

When Alex takes an accidental dive off stage while speaking at his alma mater, Whitney's reaction is less than heartwarming. Meanwhile, R.J. tries to school Mark on the art of chivalry using Lily as an example. Roxanne, Mark's intended target doesn't initially take his bait.

When Alex agrees to let his ex-fiancé Chloe crash on his couch during her stay in town without notifying Whitney, he finds himself in trouble. Instead of consoling his current significant other, he has to cater to his ex, putting Whitney in an awkward situation. Meanwhile, Roxanne lets Lily use her apartment for some alone time with a date and ends up crashing for the night with Mark.