When Honey's long-lost fiancé surfaces in Great Bend, he challenges Hoyle to a duel when he learns of their ongoing "relations." Meanwhile, things start to get more serious between Eli and Pearl.

After a group of local miscreants turns up dead, Hoyle, Eli, Honey and the gang track the killers to Cole Younger's hideout, giving Hoyle another shot at finally bringing Cole to justice.

Hoyle and the gang race to rescue one of their own after a kidnapping by the vengeful Cole Younger.