Adam discovers that Callie is deep in debt and doesn't seem to care; Mike switches with Lisa on morning baby duties and bonds with the other neighborhood mothers. Ethan tries to break up with a girl but she sees his bluff.

Callie seeks to return a lost puppy but Adam gets the credit; Mike confronts a noisy neighbor; Ethan's current girlfriend meets his shut-in neighbor in person.

Adam borrows Callie's car and allows it to be stolen. He decides to surprise her with a new one and asks the guys to help get the best deal.