The Gothic "Hanging Jail" of Deridder, Louisiana sets the stage for the Achievement Haunter crew to use their unique blend of antagonism and playful pranks to try and draw out the ghosts of a cruel jailer and two murderers who faced the jail's infamous gallows.

A historic hotel in Seguin, Texas draws the interest of the Achievement Haunter crew, who hope to make contact with the ghostly guests of the Magnolia, including two children who died under particularly tragic circumstances and a potential murderer.

In one of the most dangerous haunts yet, the Achievement Haunter crew investigates a defunct sawmill in Long Leaf, Louisiana. Wile Geoff gets an idea to ratchet up Gavin's fear Jeremy has a ghostly encounter searching for an evil foreman and his victims.