Deep in the forest of Woodside, Baldric and Hexela discover a stone soldier that leads them to a witch's lair. When they find the witch's remains, Hexela contacts the witch's spirit and uncovers a murder mystery. Meanwhile, Gretta receives a mysterious package. Unable to resist opening it, she instantly finds herself teleported onto a stormy ocean.

Baldric's brother, Brodogg, drops by Gretta's house unexpectedly and convinces Baldric to train him in magic. At the same time, Dwight and Gretta are at the mercy of their RealBaby parental-training dolls for a school project. During a sleepless night of fake baby watching, Gretta discovers Brodogg might have other motives for showing up.

Dwight's teacher appreciation brunch turns disastrous when a mysterious creature tears up the venue. But when Dwight and Gretta search for answers, they find all the witnesses are missing memories of that day. Zeke, the school reporter, may be Dwight and Gretta's only hope for getting to the bottom of the mystery.