A member of Hexela's coven, Ragana, surprises her in Woodside; Baldric, Gretta, and Dwight are roped into the escalating rivalry between the two witches.

Ragana seeks refuge in the Witches Inn while imprisoning Dwight and casting a spell over him to attempt to get wishes out of the wish turtle. Hexela, Baldric, Gretta, and Chlodwig follow Ragana to the Wtiches Inn and hatch a plan to finish the witches brawl with Ragana to release Dwight.

Dwight, Gretta, and Chlodwig get a shocking vision of their future. Gretta refuses to accept that future and makes plans for the three of them to avoid it. Hexela and Baldric take an inventory of Ragana's belongings and find way more than they can handle.