Dwight unknowingly moves a Kofewalt, unleashing a string of bad luck on himself; Gretta and Baldric try to help Dwight avoid his bad luck-induced disasters so that he can reconnect with a former crush.

The Woodside basketball team inadvertently summons an ancient Highlander warrior; Gretta and Baldric must come to Dwight's aid as he has fallen ill and cannot perform his duties as Woody the Woodchuck, Woodside's mascot.

Dwight agrees to help Gretta host an ancient version of Thanksgiving; an infinity spell causes them to live the same day over and over until they accomplish everything correctly.