Karen goes hunting for a vicious black caiman, and Florence insists on joining her. Meanwhile, the survivors have to vote on whether the pirates spoil Game of Thrones for them, and Steve and the Barracuda discover that they have more in common than they thought.

Rosa returns to make Owen face the realities of fatherhood. Meanwhile, Todd realizes that he cheated with Chet's wife.

After the prates return their luggage, Jess realizes that they're going to leave and suggests a reverse indecent proposal with one of their captors. Meanwhile, Steve tries to get through to the Barracuda's emotional side, and Owen and Florence share a burgeoning romance.