Todd and Owen find a suitcase that holds a dark secret. Meanwhile, Pack, Emma, and Florence find two DVDs and one player with only enough power to play one of the movies: Dumb and Dumber To, or Selma.

Jess and Todd argue over their future together, while Danny leads Owen to a secret place. Meanwhile, Pack demands that Chet share some of his drugs with him.

The survivors hold an election for island leader to see who has the best plan to deal with the tyrannical Todd. Meanwhile, Todd challenges Danny to a drink-off: the hidden community pile for Danny's gun.