Haskell dates a beautiful woman who Phil is convinced is really a man. Stuart is filled with guilt after he sleeps with a woman who thinks he's a war hero.

Haskell's estranged brother shows up and asks for one small favor: his kidney. Holly mentors a teenager who turns out to like Eden's job more than hers.

Holly throws a birthday party for Stuart and Nicki, but her real motive is to impress a guy she's just met who's new in town. Nicki and Stuart's dad shows up and ruins everything.