Holly begins dating basketball player Kevin Tyler, one of Phil's clients, until their sexual encounters interferes with Kevin's performance on the court. Haskell and Stuart get into sports betting.

When Holly has to face her cheating ex fiance for the first time since they broke up, she enlists the guys' help to prove to him he lost the best thing he ever had.

When the guys can't resolve their differences, Holly sends the three of them to couples' therapy, where they discover that Holly is the problem.