Mr. Chronis forces the gang to swap identities with each other in competition for a raise. Breaking character gets you Tasered and puts you out of the competition.

A shadow from Manjusha's past comes back to haunt her. Meanwhile, Cliff professes his love for another staff member, and we learn the history of "Magic Funhouse!"

Cliff suspects that Dave may be trying to murder him. Arlo tries to boost employee morale by taking his staff to laughter therapy, and Sacha engages in a turf war.