When Mike stumbles across a Viagra pill, he and Martina decide to takes it once for fun, but then become worried about going back to business as usual. Meanwhile, Stella starts a YouTube channel but can't handle the mean comments, and Shea finds her own magic pill she can't give up.

Stella scores Pearl Jam tickets for Mike through her boyfriend, but when Mike finds out the guy is married, he struggles with whether or not to tell her. Meanwhile, Martina and Bob bond at a shooting range and Alice teaches Shea how to "play it cool" with the guy she's seeing.

When Stella, Shea and Martina go to a male strip club and see Ethan there, they assume he's gay. They discover, however, that he is moonlighting as a dancer, making Shea see things in a different light. Meanwhile, Mike and Bob compete over who is more attractive to other men.