After a year, nobody has confessed to stealing Emma's diary. Suddenly, Warren Academy students realize, their secrets might just come out, as well. Maybe a certain player isn't exactly who they claim to be?

It's a new day at Warren Academy and Alex, Charlie, and Jake learn that a certain someone may be back in town. Also, the student body discovers that one of their fellow classmates may not be as nice as they seem.

Class President, Preston, may not be as perfect as he seems. In the latest Warren Academy gossip, Emma reveals Preston's darkest secret. Meanwhile, Principal Lee wants to save Warren Academy's reputation and is desperate to put an end to the drama. She asks Charlie to help her find the person that stole Emma's diary in exchange for a glowing scholarship letter. But Charlie may now be the next victim of Warren Academy's gossip...