Emma Wilson left Warren Academy after her diary was posted at Homecoming last year. Just when the school thought they had moved on, a letter from Emma has turned up. She vows to take revenge on her former friends until the person who stole her diary confesses. But who did it?

After a year, nobody has confessed to stealing Emma's diary. Suddenly, Warren Academy students realize, their secrets might just come out, as well. Maybe a certain player isn't exactly who they claim to be?

It's a new day at Warren Academy and Alex, Charlie, and Jake learn that a certain someone may be back in town. Also, the student body discovers that one of their fellow classmates may not be as nice as they seem.