Best friends and expert bakers Brenda Nibley and Elisa Barber are tasked with making their most over-the-top, fairy-inspired cookie build to be auctioned off for charity during the Fairy Festival's holiday auction. Later, the ladies come up with a jaw-dropping 3-D work of art for a local gallery wanting something special for the holidays.

Just in time for the holidays, a local zoo asks expert bakers Brenda Nibley and Elisa Barber to create a cookie build that celebrates the arrival of new polar bears. They come up with a whimsical coconut shortbread cookie display surrounded by delicious Mexican wedding cookie "snowballs" for the occasion. Next, they make a detailed citrus gingerbread dollhouse with a vanilla cake "lawn" for a holiday party.

Brenda Nibley and Elisa Barber race toward the holidays after a car-racing team asks them to build a Santa's sleigh racecar made out of chocolate peppermint shortbread surrounded by edible gift boxes. Then the tables are turned as a dad rewards Mr. and Mrs. Claus for speaking to his speech-delayed son in sign language with an edible Christmas tree and cookies from around the world.