Molly gets little help from her family as she tries to deal with her breakup with Nick---they're much too busy preparing for Halloween. Meanwhile, Harriet waits for a call back from a gentleman suitor.

Molly celebrates her 16th birthday and endures her family's bizarre rituals, which include peculiar songs and a seafood dinner at the same restaurant where cool kids from Molly's school are hanging out.

At school, Molly finds a discarded CD with an eclectic mix of love songs on it, and she sets out to find the person who recorded it. Mary, meanwhile, is angry with Jerry but won't tell him why; and Harriet meets a mime and develops an interest in the art.