Andrea and Amanda receive word from Lorin, a young FLDS man looking to escape the group. Lorin disagrees with the strict rules banning marriage and wants to leave for love, but his highly confrontational plan to escape during a crowded church service concerns everyone involved.

MaryAnn, a rule-breaking FLDS woman, reaches out to Jessica and Amanda about leaving the polygamous group. When MaryAnn's family receives word of her plan to escape, the girls must take action sooner than expected. After an emotional confrontation with her mother, MaryAnn refuses to leave until she says goodbye to her siblings in a dangerous polygamous town nearby.

Jessica recruits Rachel Jeffs, daughter of notorious leader Warren Jeffs, to help FLDS member, Carole, escape a "house of repentance". After being caught in what the religion considers a highly forbidden relationship, Carole was sent to live far away from her family and friends to be closely guarded by some of the religion's most elite and faithful women taught to protect the religion at all cost. Carole's escape from polygamy grows increasingly tense and every attempt is made by the faithful to keep Carole trapped inside the group.